What Britain can learn from Europe about changing UK Drug laws

15:20 03 January 2017

Activists demanding the legalisation of marijuana, Berlin

Activists demanding the legalisation of marijuana, Berlin


From cannabis legalisation to festival drugs testing, European countries are shaping new, progressive drugs policies, and Britain risks being left behind

A man injects himself with heroin in Platzspitz Park, Zurich, where drug addicts and dealers are tolerated, contained and controlled, circa 1990. The social experiment failed and Platzspitz was closed in 1992A man injects himself with heroin in Platzspitz Park, Zurich, where drug addicts and dealers are tolerated, contained and controlled, circa 1990. The social experiment failed and Platzspitz was closed in 1992

This July I had some illegal drugs tested at a music festival. I was told exactly how strong they were, given impartial advice on the best methods of imbibing them, and given the opportunity to surrender them. (I’ll let you decide whether I chose to.)

The testing was conducted by the drugs harm reduction organization, The Loop, at the Secret Garden Party with the approval of local police, and it felt revolutionary. It was a pragmatic response to rising numbers of ecstasy deaths, and was putting young lives before archaic British drugs legislation.

The Loop’s well publicized work over the summer, and the good-will it generated amongst the clubbing and festival going community was knocked out of the limelight by last month’s closure of Fabric after two ecstasy-related deaths on the premises. These two events occurred just months apart but sum up the schizophrenic nature of British drugs policy, which is at odds with the progressive drug strategies of our European neighbours. Whether its the blanket decriminalisation of Portugal or the Czech Republic, or the proposed advances in cannabis legislation in Germany and The Netherlands, the UK looks increasingly stuck in the dark ages of drugs reform.

“This year there have been quite a few small steps forward, but some major jumps backwards,” says George McBride, head of advocacy at Volte Face, a policy hub aiming to change the country’s legal approach to drugs from one of prohibition to pragmatism, harm reduction and (eventually) self-regulation.

Drug use in PortugalDrug use in Portugal

In 2015 there were a record 2,479 drug-related deaths in England and Wales, up 10% from 2014, and our drug laws wilfully ignore the socio-economic and personal realities that inform both recreational and problematic drug use.

Volte Face are far from being a lone voice though. As examples of an ever broadening coalition of political support, McBride points to the recent cross-parliamentary report on the efficacy of medical cannabis, and the Liberal Democrats coming out in support of the regulation of cannabis. Tory MP Crispin Blunt also hit the headlines when he came out in support of a fully regulated drugs market and admitted to his own use of poppers.

On the other hand, 2016 saw the introduction of the misguided Psychoactive Substances Act in May. Conceived as a way to cut off the supply of so-called ‘legal highs’ by making their sale or production illegal, it mainly succeeded in turning them into a street commodity where the most vulnerable users can find them, and also created a keen market in prisons.

With the Brexit vote pushing drugs policy further down the agenda and a new Prime Minister with what McBride calls a “less than stellar history on drug policy,” those campaigning for reform in the UK could be forgiven for casting covetous eyes towards our European neighbours.

In Germany they’re a matter of months away from legalising the purchase of medical cannabis. It’s been a long road to this point, with a number of organisations behind the Legalise campaign, not least Deutscher Hanfverband, a cannabis focused think tank. Georg Wurth of the organisation says that: “In 20 years [they] have seen a big shift in public opinion towards marijuana. Medical cannabis has a huge majority now with recent data suggesting 82% of Germans support it for medical purposes.”

Public opinion towards a formal legalisation finally swayed earlier this year when multiple sclerosis sufferer Michael Fischer ended a ten year battle, winning a landmark case enabling him to cultivate his own cannabis, and in May the German government approved a proposal to develop a national medical marijuana program. “I always thought we would win the battle,” says Wurth. “Medical cannabis is just a question of humanity.”

This individual-focused approach also lies at the heart of Portugal’s trailblazing drugs policy. Implemented in 2001 as a reaction to the enormous problems enveloping the nation - an estimated 1% of its population were addicted to heroin - it decriminalised the possession of small amounts of all drugs.

Portugal’s problems were born out of a complicated history; nearly 50 years under the prohibitive dictatorial regime of Estado Novo meant the experimental countercultures of the sixties had passed them by. By the time Estado Novo collapsed in 1974 there’s was a nation ready, desperate, to let it all hang out.

“We associated drug use with freedom,” says Dr João Goulão. In 1998 Goulão was part of a board tasked with formulating a new drugs strategy for the country. “At the heart of the strategy was the reality that we were dealing with a health and social condition, rather than a criminal one.”

As well as providing syringe exchanges, treatment centres and methadone programs for heroin users, at the apex of the 2001 legislation was the implementation of ‘dissuasion panels’. If an individual is caught with an amount of drugs classified as personal use - classified as enough for ten days - they do not get a criminal record, but are sent to a panel where they are encouraged to reflect on the nature of their drug use.

“The goal is to find difficulties you are facing that, when coexisting with drugs, could lead to problematic drug use; maybe your parents are divorcing, or you might be in conflict with your sexuality. You could then be offered an appointment to talk to a psychologist to support you. It is free and the decision is yours. Everything is anonymous.”

This kind of super holistic approach might seem like anathema to Theresa May and her right wing drug warriors, but the results speak for themselves. Portugal has a drug-induced death rate of just three per million people, as opposed to a 17.3 across the EU and 44.6 in the UK. The number of heroin addicts has halved to roughly 50,000, and drug use overall has declined across 15-24 year olds.

It’s not just Germany and Portugal that are lighting the path towards progressive drugs reform. Switzerland advocated a similarly humane reaction to its heroin epidemic of the late eighties; they’ve also got, in Dr Peter Gasser, the only person in the world that’s legally allowed to prescribe LSD. The Czech Republic, like Portugal, has decriminalised drugs for personal use and implemented a four point National Drug Policy Strategy based around the reduction of drug use and availability.

The Netherlands, as any teenager with an Interrail ticket in their back pocket will affirm, has long had a more tolerant attitude towards cannabis and soft drugs, and their wheels are slowly turning towards regulated marijuana cultivation.

Over the course of 2017, however, eyes will be mostly keenly trained across the Atlantic, at Uruguay, the United States and Canada. All are in various phases of new cannabis legalisation, with the latter due to fully legalise its recreational use next spring.

A huge marker for Canada’s drug future was laid when their Minister for Health, Jane Philpott, addressed the UNGASS (UN General Assembly Special Session on Drugs) conference in April and accepted that the country was not doing enough to help its citizens when it came to drugs. In her speech, she spoke of being inspired by a Canadian mother called Donna May who has been tirelessly campaigning for reform ever since her daughter, Jac, died of a heroin overdose.

May is part of Anyone’s Child; an inspirational worldwide network of bereaved families and friends who have lost loved ones to drugs. They are campaigning for drugs policy reform across the world, and stories like theirs are vital in framing the narrative for the populace and setting in motion the sort of public opinion swing that will propel politicians into action. Because for many people, record numbers of drug-related deaths are just a number, with festival drugs testing the sort of activity they would never engage in. But a mother losing their child? Anyone with a heart can empathise with that.

David Hillier is a Brighton-based writer, journalist and festival nerd. You’ll find him in The Guardian, Vice, Wonderland and tweeting @Gobshout

Latest articles

BrexFactor: The 10 WORST Brexiteers this week

Confused by another week in Brexit? We round up the losers and the losers (because there are no winners) of another crazy seven days on Planet Brexit

Euro rich list: The 48 richest people in Europe

Just who are the wealthiest people in Europe? We found out how much they’re worth

The unravelling of Turkey: a frightening illustration of a country unleashed from EU aspirations

Turkey was on progressive path, but Europe sent it in a dangerous direction

You are a fascist if you do these 14 things

What constitutes a fascist – and is it fair to categorise Trump, The Leader of the Free World, alongside Benito Mussolini, Adolf Hitler and Francisco Franco?

The true defenders of democracy are those who don’t give up the fight

British democracy has been an inspiration round the globe. Now it is time to defend it.

My problem with Piers Morgan

Piers Morgan and Milo Yiannopoulos share more than a love of attention: Society needs provocateurs, but it also needs us to see them for what they are

Blair’s new role: To temper romanticism with realism

There’s more to Tony Blair’s baggage than Iraq. But if he really is “back”, he does have the power to alter the terms of the Brexit debate

48 questions all Leavers have to answer

The Brextremists’ only response to Tony Blair’s speech was abuse. We should take heart from their refusal to engage on the substance – and force them to answer these 48 questions

The New European says: Thank you, our readers, for all your support so far!

No other media embodies a sense of community like a newspaper does.

NHS staff shortage looms: 1000s of doctors consider quitting because of Brexit

Four in 10 European doctors are considering quitting Britain following the Brexit vote in a move that would “cripple” the NHS.

What food is to me: We steal from our own memories and serve it on a plate

These top chefs shared how lesser known European dishes and ingredients have inspired their own work

Child refugees: We don’t need history to tell us how to respond to this crisis

The current batch of refugee children travelling across Europe desperate to escape unimaginable horrors at home prompt chilling echoes of Jewish youngsters arriving in the UK in the late 1930s

Brexit is about the rich Rees-Moggs of Britain, not anyone else

To get to the dark heart of Brexit, ask who benefits? The tiny cabal who might conceivably prosper from Brexit tell you exactly why we must continue to resist it.

This is why the prognosis is now critical for our NHS

If you want to know what’s going wrong in the NHS don’t listen to MPs, just follow the money

The new Cold War: In Trump’s warped mind, the EU is a rival to be destroyed

The shifting sands of geopolitics has seen a frost descend on US-EU relations. But if we are to have a new Cold War - between Trump and Europe – he will lose

This is the email that will make the Lords battle a Hard Brexit

I am a peer in the House of Lords preparing to fight Article 50

Will Ted Malloch be Trump’s anti-EU ambassador in Brussels?

Vanquisher of the Soviet Union, Thatcher’s “genius” or Europe’s best bullshitter? Whichever he is, Ted Malloch could soon be the EU’s worst nightmare.

Assessing the talent in the House of Commons (on both sides of the Brexit debate)

Romanticism always outshines stoicism, but the cavaliers left a terrible mess behind, says Michael White

Hate is easy, beguiling and powerful... but we can stop it

We are living in an era when hate seems to be in the ascendency, says Eddie Izzard. But there is a way to fight back



Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter