Brexit is a revolution that devours its children

PUBLISHED: 13:34 23 June 2017 | UPDATED: 13:35 23 June 2017

Francisco de Goya, Saturno devorando a su hijo (1819-1823)

Francisco de Goya, Saturno devorando a su hijo (1819-1823)

Archant

Brexit is the ‘third rail’ of politics – touch it and you are dead. But a sane strategy could yet emerge

Brexit is a revolution that devours its children. It has consumed three prime ministers – Thatcher, Major and Cameron. It is destroying a fourth – May.

In the last year alone it has decapitated a Chancellor, neutered both a Foreign Secretary and the next Chancellor, and already two of the three ministers in the new Brexit department have exited.

Brexit is the ‘third rail’ of modern British politics. Touch it and you are dead.

The revolution wreaks havoc hour by hour and it is quite possible that Theresa May will have resigned by the time you read this. But if she survives for a short while it is for one reason only: no-one else wants to assume the opprobrium of the Brexit negotiations, particularly agreeing a figure for the ‘exit bill’, which will be in the tens of billions and is already becoming the object of the next vitriolic Daily Mail and Sun campaign against the evil empire.

May’s position is similar to that of the hapless Earl of Shelburne, one of Britain’s shortest lived and least regarded premiers, who had the hapless task of negotiating the treaty of independence for the victorious American colonies in the 1780s. He was discarded within days of it being signed. My prediction, for what it is worth (not much), is that if May resigns before the exit terms are agreed, her successor will not survive the Brexit negotiations. Revolutions typically get, swiftly, through two generations of leaders before the tumult subsides.

Whoever is in No 10, what should their policy be? The Hard Brexit of May’s Lancaster House speech of January 17 – leaving both the customs union and the single market, and “no deal is better than a bad deal” – was disowned this week by her Chancellor, Philip Hammond, and is now being intensely fought in the Cabinet. Hammond is seeking to secure at least a lengthy transition phase of membership of the Norway-led European Economic Area – which might then end up as the basis for a long-term deal, if the Soft Brexiteers triumph over the Jacobin Hard Brexiteers.

If David Davis and Liam Fox’s Jacobins win, the UK will probably end up in a WTO rules-based arrangement beyond a more scrappy transition, with trade tariffs and a nightmare prospect of negotiating bilateral trade deals with the countries currently covered by EU trade agreements.

At stake is not only tariff and trade regulations but also the regime for dozens of vital national activities, from air travel to nuclear safety and research. What happens to these is anyone’s guess.

The position of the DUP is critical to the internecine strife. Because of the Remain majority in Northern Ireland, and their desire to avoid a hard border with either Ireland or the British mainland, the DUP support membership of the single market and the customs union.

Crucial to the Soft – ie, ‘sane’ – Brexit option is the attitude taken by President Macron. He is already sharing the leadership of Europe with Chancellor Merkel and may soon take it over entirely. If May or her successor decide upon a Hard Brexit, he has every incentive to drive a hard bargain, since the policy of the British government will be precisely to secure one.

However, if ‘sane Brexit’ becomes UK policy, the incentives change. If the UK wants serious engagement, a strategic-minded French president ought to want to secure this, for the benefit of trade with its second largest neighbour and to underpin the long-term security of the Continent. A stark fact is that when Britain leaves the EU, 80% of NATO resources will also be outside the EU, hardly a strong and stable environment for the union.

A key issue will be freedom of movement to work. The main concern for most of those who voted for Brexit is uncontrolled immigration. This is where they really want to “take back control”.

Free movement of people to work is not – whatever Jean-Claude Juncker says – an indispensable condition for an effective single European market. It may be a requirement for a single European state, but that is another matter.

Does Macron share this view? Jean Pisani-Ferry, a senior Macron campaign adviser, said recently: “There can be no doubt that the Leave campaign tapped into seams of genuine concern about the scale and speed of immigration. Free movement of workers is not indispensable for the smooth functioning of economic integration in goods, services and capital.” He added, pointedly: “We therefore contradict the current view of the EU president.”

The Pisani-Ferry thesis is heresy in Brussels, where the four freedoms – like the Holy Trinity – are held to be one and indivisible. Since the heretic opined injudiciously in public, Macron has not made him a Minister nor taken him (yet) in the Élysée. But that does not make his argument any less valid or serviceable.

If Britain were allowed to restrict free movement of workers while remaining in the single market and customs union, parliament, not the EU, would decide a national immigration policy. But there would continue to be an unrestricted right to travel and study freely across the EU, and the rights of existing residents would be guaranteed. So about three-and-three-quarters of the four freedoms would be guaranteed.

If Paris was worth a mass, sane Brexit might be worth one sixteenth of Brussels orthodoxy.

Crucially, there would be no need for immensely complex negotiations over trade and much else, which are virtually certain to result in acrimony and damage both to Britain and the rest of Europe.

What would Britain’s best immigration policy be on this scenario? That depends on your view of the relationship between immigration and opportunities for British workers, particularly low skilled young people who are faring so badly in today’s job market. Some controls may be justified, if they go hand in hand with radical reform of technical education, to equip the half of young people who do not go on to higher education with skills for tomorrow’s jobs.

Critically, the government would be responding to the much-vaunted “instruction of the British people” to leave the EU, but without undermining our trade and security in a way never intended by most of those who voted Leave. And our European allies would be reconstituting the ‘European economic area’ to make it viable for the future, with an outer ring in which national sovereignty plays a greater role.

Oh, and the treaty with the victorious American colonies was .... the Peace of Paris. As for the benighted Earl of Shelburne, he never held office again. But his protégé, William Pitt, became Britain’s youngest and longest serving prime minister. For most of his tenure, he was at war with France.

Lord Adonis is chairman of the National Infrastructure Commission. He served in the Labour governments of Tony Blair and Gordon Brown, holding posts including Transport Secretary and Schools Minister

Support The New European's vital role as a voice for the 48%

The New European is proud of its journalism and we hope you are proud of it too. We believe our voice is important - both in representing the pro-EU perspective and also to help rebalance the right wing extremes of much of the UK national press. If you value what we are doing, you can help us by making a contribution to the cost of our journalism.

  • Become a friend of The New European for a contribution of £48. You will qualify for a mention in our newspaper (should you wish)
  • Become a partner of The New European for a contribution of £240. You will qualify for a mention in our newspaper (should you wish) and receive a New European Branded Pen and Notebook
  • Become a patron of The New European for a contribution of £480. You will qualify for a mention in our newspaper (should you wish) and receive a New European Branded Pen and Notebook and an A3 print of The New European front cover of your choice, signed by Editor Matt Kelly

By proceeding, you agree to the New Europeans supporters club Terms & Conditions which can be found here.



Supporter Options

Mention Me in The New European



If Yes, Name to appear in The New European



Latest Articles

Friday, November 17, 2017

Somaliland is introducing the world’s most advanced voting system. It is, says CALESTOUS JUMA, just one example of the way African countries are surprisingly skipping ahead in technological innovation

Saturday, November 18, 2017

Britain’s bungled Brexit negotiations have sparked a messy divorce from the European Union – and it is about to get even nastier.

Friday, November 17, 2017

PAUL CONNEW on the ongoing investigations into the Trump administration's Kremlin links

Tuesday, November 14, 2017

Georgia spawned Stalin, the monster who forever poisoned the legacy of the Russian Revolution. But it also produced a tantalising alternative vision of what that revolution could have led to. JUSTIN REYNOLDS explores the forgotten history of the fleeting Democratic Republic of Georgia, which offered a flicker of hope before it was extinguished

Friday, November 17, 2017

Comedian, musician and writer MITCH BENN on a year in which politics is quite literally crazy

Friday, November 17, 2017

Britain’s tech sector is flying. But, asks ANGELA JAMESON, will new Government cash be enough to stop Brexit bursting the bubble?

Friday, November 17, 2017

This week’s New European Podcast has dropped - and we are focusing on Brexit’s dreamiest couple.

Thursday, November 16, 2017

What makes some men act inappropriately? Psychiatry professor PHILIP GRAHAM explores the science behind harassment

Thursday, November 16, 2017

STEVE ANGLESEY counts down the worst Brexiteers of the week

Tuesday, November 14, 2017

In his most celebrated poems, Rupert Brooke gave a classic evocation of England. But, argues CHARLIE CONNELLY, his work has a very European context

Wednesday, November 15, 2017

RICHARD PORRITT with the week's big stories

Tuesday, November 14, 2017

Tim Martin, boss of the Wetherspoon pub chain, is pestering drinkers with his pro-Brexit beer mats. ANTHONY CLAVANE wonders whether his customers might find it too much to swallow

Tuesday, November 14, 2017

The internet does not distinguish between good and bad. If we want to survive it, we might have to, says NATHANIEL TAPLEY

Monday, November 13, 2017

What do the Hard Brexiteers think of ‘taking back control’ only to have the US wade into the UK’s trading standards? ANGELA JAMESON investigates whether chlorinated chicken is back on the menu

Tuesday, November 14, 2017

Almost half of NHS doctors from Europe are considering quitting the UK because of Brexit, according to a new survey.

Monday, November 13, 2017

MPs will get the chance to vote down Brexit in parliament – but we will leave the EU whatever the result, David Davis has said.

Monday, November 13, 2017

PAUL CONNEW on how, despite everything, the President retains his support base

Monday, November 13, 2017

As the Brexit Bill continues its chaotic progress through the Commons, pro-European peer HUGH DYKES warns that the Lords are ready to take up the fight when it reaches them

Friday, November 10, 2017

Research by the British Election Study suggests the ethnic minority vote was crucial in the EU referendum.

Friday, November 10, 2017

The playwright, author and critic on the fight against change

Friday, November 10, 2017

Editor-at-large ALASTAIR CAMPBELL on why leaving the EU is so damaging to the health service

Friday, November 10, 2017

Being forced to wear one takes all meaning away from this symbol, says comedian, musician and writer MITCH BENN

Monday, November 13, 2017

For a true idea of the untold tragedy of gun crime in the US, look beyond the mass shootings to the ‘mundane’ murders. ANDREW PURCELL reports

Thursday, November 9, 2017

Britain’s unofficial poet laureate Tony Harrison tells ANTHONY CLAVANE about how the divisions exposed by his landmark poem, V, are as raw now as ever

Friday, November 10, 2017

Article 50, which triggers Britain's exit from the EU, can be reversed, according to the man who wrote it.

Thursday, November 9, 2017

RICHARD PORRITT rounds up the losers and losers (because there are no winners) of another crazy seven days on Planet Brexit

Thursday, November 9, 2017

RICHARD PORRITT with the week's big stories

Tuesday, November 7, 2017

CHRIS SUTCLIFFE on media

Tuesday, November 7, 2017

A new international study shows how narcissism and an unrealistic belief in national greatness led to the successes of Donald Trump and Brexit. SCOTT OLIVER reports

Tuesday, November 7, 2017

The government has announced there will be a delay of "no more than three weeks" in publishing its secret papers on the economic impact of Brexit.

Tuesday, November 7, 2017

PETER TRUDGILL on the Nordic roots of a French wine

Monday, November 6, 2017

Is the House of cards about to fall? PAUL CONNEW examines a blockbuster week in the White House as the Russian Connection begins to really bite

Monday, November 6, 2017

Turkey has just got its 93rd political party. But, says SUNA ERDEM, the Good Party and its leader Meral Aksener could bring the troubled country the rejuvenation it desperately needs

Friday, November 3, 2017

Andy Wigmore's attempt at 'sarcasm' on Vote Leave's use of bots was a characteristic piece of mischief from this sharpshooting Brexiteer, say RACHEL DAVIS and RICHARD PORRITT

Friday, November 3, 2017

President Xi Jinping’s position is strengthened and his vision for China is clear. But, says CHARLES BURTON, it means he will have to take the blame if things go wrong

Friday, November 3, 2017

With Donald Trump doing his best to up the ante in his stand-off with Kim Jong-Un, the optimistic argument goes that China will eventually step in to restrain its North Korean neighbour. But, KATHARINE MOON argues, this is wishful thinking. Pyongyang won’t kowtow to Beijing

Friday, November 3, 2017

Throughout his career, the designer acted as a curator of his own work. As our culture correspondent VIV GROSKOP reports, we now have two museums fit to showcase that talent

Friday, November 3, 2017

EMMA JONES recalls her time working in the magazine industry with its very warped view of women

Friday, November 3, 2017

Britain has never produced another hero like Dan Dare. In a landmark year for the lantern-jawed pilot, CHARLIE CONNELLY pays tribute to a figure who has shaped our art, literature, science, architecture and even musical theatre

Friday, November 3, 2017

RICHARD MILLS on the sometimes surreal, sometimes tragic, story of Vladimir Dedijer, a Yugoslav partisan fighter, member of Tito’s inner circle and a big Huddersfield Town fan

Podcast

Trending

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter