Brexiteers are banging on about EU food myths to deflect from the real disaster

PUBLISHED: 17:37 16 April 2017 | UPDATED: 17:41 16 April 2017

Bananas took a starring role in the Brexit brigade's  myth-ridden narrative

Bananas took a starring role in the Brexit brigade's myth-ridden narrative

mazzzur

The Brexit brigade is still going on about bendy bananas and the return of imperial measures. But it is a strategy born of ignorance or – worse – panic

For many of its advocates, Brexit seems mostly an exercise in nostalgia – hence preoccupations with things like blue passports, a new royal yacht and war with Spain.

Another fixation which seems to be gathering momentum of late is a return to imperial weights and measures. It was Iain Duncan Smith, the former cabinet minister, who got the ball rolling recently by including it in his list of demands for a root and branch review of EU legislation on the UK statute book before 2020.

Among things he wanted scrapping were the working time directive and, oddly, legal protection of the great crested newt. But as a trading standards professional for more than 20 years, it was the weights and measures which caught my eye – as well as another favoured trope of the Brexiteers.... the abolition of EU regulations on bent bananas.

I am a qualified Food Standards Officer and Inspector of Weights and Measures. During my career I have advised countless businesses on consumer protection and food safety issues. A significant proportion of my career has involved enforcing weights and measures law and I was closely involved with the Metric Martyrs controversy. Now, almost 20 years on from the abolition of imperial units for trade use in the UK, we have high-profile politicians calling for their return.

Also in support of such a move is Andrea Leadsom, the secretary of state for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs – seemingly unaware that it is her government’s policy that the UK should retain a single measurements system based on the metric system.

Central to the statements of both Duncan Smith and Leadsom seems to be the belief that metric units of measurement were imposed on the UK through European regulation. If that is what these two senior politicians believe, they couldn’t be more wrong.

The process of metrication began in the mid-1960s when Harold Wilson’s Labour government announced a modernisation plan for Britain. This included Wilson’s ‘white heat of technology’ speech.

Over the next 30 years, sector by sector, Britain moved to the metric system abandoning most imperial measures. The last sector to go metric was the sale of consumer goods from bulk, such as fruit and vegetables. Certain items such as the pint for beer and cider were specifically excluded from the metrication process, in perpetuity.

Metrication was not imposed on the UK by Europe. It was the result of decisions and legislation made by successive UK parliaments at Westminster. Only a very small number of weights and measures laws have anything to do with the EU. They are nearly all UK domestic law. Parliament could legislate for a return to imperial weights and measures at any time with no effect on our EU membership.

Harold Wilson’s decision to go metric was directly related to the UK being a signatory of the International Organisation of Legal Metrology treaty, which we signed in 1856. Metric measures became legal for trade use in the UK in 1875, nearly 100 years before we joined the EEC.

So if Duncan Smith is wrong about the EU imposing metric units on the UK, what truth is there in his claim that EU regulations ban bananas with excessive curvature?

The myth of EU regulations banning overly bent bananas, or other misshapen fruits and vegetables, has been circulating for decades. Like all good tales, it has a minute grain of truth which has been greatly exaggerated for political advantage.

The EU certainly has quality standards for bananas – to allow them to be traded internationally, and provide standards so consumers know what they are buying. But this does not mean a ban on any particular shape, rather, it means different classifications: in general, bananas should be “free from malformation or abnormal curvature”; Class 1 bananas are permitted to have “slight defects of shape”, and Class 2, “full-on defects of shape”. The classifications were developed with the approval of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development in order to improve the lot of banana farmers. Over the years, these regulations have been a tinkered with a bit.

But what has never changed – and this is a point worth repeating – is that there has never been a ban. Instead it means bent bananas sell for a lower price, and are more likely to be used in industrial food production, for products such as smoothies, rather than being placed on display at your local greengrocers.

The bendy banana myth seems to have first appeared in 1994, when EU-wide fruit quality standards were first being discussed. It must be noted that these EU-wide regulations replaced almost identical UK domestic quality standards for fruit and vegetables. Stories in the Daily Mirror, the Sun, the Daily Mail and the Daily Express claiming that there was such an EU ban were published that year. In 1998, the Sun ran the story again. It was one of countless EU myths published in UK papers since we joined the EEC in 1972.

Boris Johnson used the claim during the 2015 EU referendum campaign where he also incorrectly stated that there was an EU rule on the number of bananas in a bunch (no such rule exists and law on what fruits can be sold by the bunch is contained in a UK statutory instrument under the Weights and Measures Act 1985).

Since the early 1990s similar stories have also appeared in relation to the length of leeks, the colour of apples and the straightness of cucumbers. Each and every time such stories appear, the EU has to publish a rebuttal. Perhaps we should be more concerned about the amount of time and money the EU has had to spend countering spurious claims made by the UK press and our politicians?

The bendy banana ban wasn’t the worst EU fruit and veg myth circulated during the EU referendum. A related internet meme stated that the EU regulations on cabbages contained 26,911 words.

This meme was examined by BBC Radio 4’s More or Less, the statistics and fact checking programme. It found that the myth originated in pricing regulations for cabbages made by the US federal government during the Second World War. The US pricing regulations contained 2,600 words. Somehow, by the mid-1990s the number of words regarding US law on the pricing of cabbages had expanded to 26,911. US Senator Orrin Hatch of Utah, used this word count on the floor of the Senate in a debate on agriculture standards. In 2006, the 26,911 word count jumped the Atlantic and Lord Ramsbotham of Kensington used it in a Lord’s debate on the EU duck egg exportation directive. The claim is completely false.

In truth, the EU quality standards for cabbages ran to only 2,000 words. They were revoked in 2009. The UK Red Tractor farm assurance scheme issues protocols on the growth and production of cabbages. For comparison, the current Red Tractor guidance runs to 23,510 words.

So why do eurosceptic politicians and newspaper columnists keep on using these tired EU myths? After all, they won the vote and Article 50 has been triggered. I doubt that Duncan Smith or his colleagues truly believe these stories. I suspect these myths are being used to deflect from greater problems with Brexit. That those now in charge of the process did not expect their cause to win and they have absolutely no idea what to do next.

Pippa Musgrave is a qualified Food Standards Officer, an Inspector of Weights and Measures and a member of the Chartered Institute of Trading Standards

DECADES OF EU FOOD MYTHS

Claim: Britain’s best-loved foods could be threatened by a flood of foreign imitations under EU trade deal

Made in: Sun on Sunday, September 2016

The Sun on Sunday reported that TTIP, the now defunct EU trade agreement with the USA and CETA, the EU’s trade agreement with Canada would result in low quality copies of classic British foods flooding into the market. Products mentioned included Cornish Pasties, Cumberland Sausage and Stilton.

The EU clearly stated that each of these products were protected under EU law through either PGI or PDO status. There was no chance that products made in America would be allowed to use those names. Indeed both the US and Canadian trade agreements sought to extend these protections beyond the EU single market.

This report was published after the EU referendum. It is interesting to note that the UK leaving the EU will end protected status for many UK foods. Brexit may result in cheap foreign versions of foods currently protected in the EU entering the UK market from foreign producers.

Claim: Italian cheese makers are furious after the EU allowed mozzarella to be made with powdered milk.

Made in: Daily Telegraph, June 2015

This claim was immediately debunked by the EU. Instead of permitting the making of mozzarella cheese with powdered milk, the EU was banning the process. The applicable EU rules prohibited cheese made from powdered milk being sold anywhere in Europe under the descriptions mozzarella, gorgonzola, parmigiano reggiano or provolone. Most of these cheeses were protected by European food quality schemes such as protection of designations of origin, protected geographic indications and traditional speciality guaranteed.

Claim: Brussels is trying to restrict the drinking habits of Britain’s coffee lovers

Made in: Daily Express, May 2015

The EU gave this claim short shrift, describing it as ‘utter rubbish’. They stated that it was inconceivable that the EU ever could – or would want to – restrict people from drinking as much coffee as they liked. What the Express was referring to was applications by makers of energy drinks as to the health benefits of the caffeine in their products. This was part of an ongoing process of health claims certification being undertaken by the European Food Standards Authority. EFSA had issued guidance that drinking up to 400mg per day of coffee (four strong cups of coffee) did not raise safety concerns for non-pregnant adults.

Claim: The EU want yoghurt made in Britain to be rebranded ‘Fermented Milk Pudding’

Made in: Sunday Mirror, March 2006

Fact: Following the article the EU stated that it had no plans to rename yoghurt. Discussions had taken place on a harmonised definition of yoghurt making it easier for manufacturers to trade across Europe. This included some UK yoghurt manufacturers whose products could not be sold under French law. No official proposals were made at the time.

The Mirror’s article seemed to be recycled from stories published in both the Daily Express and the Daily Telegraph in 2003 which stated that yoghurt was to be renamed ‘fermented milk’. The EU also responded to both these stories stating they were untrue.

Claim: Lemon Curd and Mincemeat may have to be renamed because the EU believe consumers on the continent may think their labels refer to dairy or red meat products

Made in: Daily Mail, October 2002

Fact: The EU responded to this story stating that terms such as ‘mince pie’ and ‘lemon curd’ were not being banned, although new food labelling rules were being considered.The new labelling rules were to apply to a strictly defined set of foodstuffs, not including lemon curd, and that bakery wares, pastries and biscuits, such as mince pies, were exempted from them.

Claim: EU chiefs have forced British food firm Colman’s to scrap its French mustard.

Made in: The Sun, April 2001

Fact: The EU pointed out that this was a decision made by Colman’s when its parent company Unilever bought their French Rival Amora-Maille. The EU competition commission was worried that with the purchase of Amora-Maille, Unilever would have a monopoly on the production of mustard. In order to comply with competition rules, Unilever decided to drop Colman’s French mustard but to continue to produce the Amora-Maille product.

Claim: The Queen has been told that the Sandringham Estate must stop selling wood in imperial measures within two weeks or trading standards officers will prosecute.

Made in: Daily Telegraph, January 2001

The EU responded stating that the decision to abandon imperial units was that of the UK government and it had nothing to do with the UK’s membership of the European Union. The EU pointed out that the decision of the UK to metricate was first made by Harold Wilson in 1965, before the UK joined the EEC and that the process had taken place, sector by sector, over the next 30 years.

Claim: What is labelled ‘Cornish Clotted Cream’ can now be made in Brittany, thanks to the EU

Made in: Sunday Telegraph, March 1998

Fact: Cornish Clotted Cream was to be protected by an EU-wide Protection of Geographic Indication as of the beginning of July 1998. The French ministry of agriculture had objected to the Cornish Clotted Cream producers application for PGI status, but this objection had been withdrawn. With the PGI coming into effect, it would be illegal to describe clotted cream produced in Brittany as Cornish.

Source: Euromyths, EU Europa website

Support The New European's vital role as a voice for the 48%

The New European is proud of its journalism and we hope you are proud of it too. We believe our voice is important - both in representing the pro-EU perspective and also to help rebalance the right wing extremes of much of the UK national press. If you value what we are doing, you can help us by making a contribution to the cost of our journalism.

  • Become a friend of The New European for a contribution of £48. You will qualify for a mention in our newspaper (should you wish)
  • Become a partner of The New European for a contribution of £240. You will qualify for a mention in our newspaper (should you wish) and receive a New European Branded Pen and Notebook
  • Become a patron of The New European for a contribution of £480. You will qualify for a mention in our newspaper (should you wish) and receive a New European Branded Pen and Notebook and an A3 print of The New European front cover of your choice, signed by Editor Matt Kelly

By proceeding, you agree to the New Europeans supporters club Terms & Conditions which can be found here.



Supporter Options

Mention Me in The New European



If Yes, Name to appear in The New European



Latest Articles

Wednesday, October 18, 2017

New Ukip leader Henry Bolton named the party's new 'shadow cabinet' today - and what a bunch they are

Tuesday, October 17, 2017

Catalonians against self-rule came out in their thousands the weekend before last.

Tuesday, October 17, 2017

It might seem quixotic, at a time when Spain looks like it is falling apart, but could the country’s future lie in a union with neighbour Portugal? DAVID BARKER investigates ‘Iberism’

Tuesday, October 17, 2017

ALEXANDRA HADDOW on the Nordic trendsetters who have style sussed

Tuesday, October 17, 2017

A second referendum that reverses Brexit would have a "positive" and "significant" impact on the UK economy, which is on track to be crippled by its EU divorce, an influential think tank claimed today.

Tuesday, October 17, 2017

Making money is no longer enough for firms, say ANGELA JAMESON

Tuesday, October 17, 2017

The question, in a quiet voice, came from a woman in the audience at the Henley Festival’s Brexit debate, in a quiet voice: “So what do I tell my children now? They planned to live and work for a time in Europe. What now?”

Tuesday, October 17, 2017

Millions of families already struggling with soaring prices could end up being another £500 worse off if Britain crashes out of the European Union without a deal, according to a report.

Monday, October 16, 2017

A day of action across the UK saw thousands of people take to the streets to demand Brexit is stopped.

Friday, October 13, 2017

People have been asking me if I know Simon Brodkin, the character-comedian/prankster who interrupted the Prime Minister’s conference speech to hand her a mock redundancy notice.

Friday, October 13, 2017

Angela Merkel’s power has taken a blow in the wake of the German election. Here Tony Paterson reports from Berlin on the new shape of German politics.

Tuesday, October 10, 2017

Roland Garros had every intention of pursuing a career as a concert pianist. An air show outside Reims during the late summer of 1909 changed all that.

Wednesday, October 11, 2017

The Chancellor has admitted no Brexit deal could leave planes grounded in March 2019.

Tuesday, October 10, 2017

The Catalonian crisis has put Europe, as well as Spain, in jeopardy, says PAUL KNOTT.

Tuesday, October 10, 2017

It’s not a stretch to say that the economics of digital advertising are to blame for disasters like Brexit and Trump.

Tuesday, October 10, 2017

Boris Johnson is desperate to get into Number 10 – but it seems the Prime Minister has other ideas.

Tuesday, October 10, 2017

We’re living in the Age of Cool Dad, with politicians obsessed with burnishing their pop culture credentials, says SAMIRA AHMED.

Monday, October 9, 2017

Theresa May has claimed “the ball is in their court” in a statement to the House of Commons updating MPs on the Brexit negotiations. Brussels, however, disagree.

Monday, October 9, 2017

By attempting to quash the result before it was even known, Madrid has made the case for Catalan independence all but unanswerable.

Monday, October 9, 2017

Lawyers have told the Government that Article 50 is not binding and can be scrapped at any time before the March 2019 deadline, it has been claimed.

Monday, October 9, 2017

The deluded fantasies of Leavers must have been inspired by the big screen says Have I Got News For You writer NATHANIEL TAPLEY. Here, he brings you the most Brexity films of all time.

Monday, October 9, 2017

France might be home of its most famous race, but Italy is the country with cycling in its DNA. To find out why, Patrick Sawer makes a tearful pilgrimage to its shrine to the sport.

Sunday, October 8, 2017

Trieste, the city which has survived centuries of seductive illusions.

Sunday, October 8, 2017

As ambitions go, Lee Humphries’ is an unusual, if lofty, one – to ascend the highest points of 100 different countries. As he crests the halfway mark in his quest, he explains all to Julian Shea.

Friday, October 6, 2017

PETER TRUDGILL traces the clockwork progress of the word ‘orange’ from southern India to northern Europe, and finds the odd detour.

Friday, October 6, 2017

JUSTIN REYNOLDS on the Thomas Mann novel which tried to make sense of the descent of Europe’s most cultured nation into Nazism.

Thursday, October 5, 2017

In the days before Stephen Paddock reignited America’s gun control debate by raining down rapid fire carnage on the Las Vegas strip, a familiar voice was again calling the shots inside Donald Trump’s head.

Friday, October 6, 2017

Ahead of the return to London of arguably his greatest work, Glengarry Glen Ross, Charlie Connelly considers the craft of polymath and playwright David Mamet.

Thursday, October 5, 2017

As with other such tragedies, the Las Vegas massacre quickly brought out the worst of the internet, says JONO READ.

Thursday, October 5, 2017

They have a new leader, but do they have a new purpose? RICHARD PORRITT went behind enemy lines at the UKIP conference and found a party on the brink.

Thursday, October 5, 2017

Spain is facing an existential threat, says JASON WALSH, with the country’s fragile compromise – which has held since the end of Franco’s dictatorship – now in tatters.

Thursday, October 5, 2017

What does it say about the Conservative government that Boris Johnson, a man whose record for lying, cheating and disgracing himself on the national stage stands alone in our political history, is not only tolerated in government, but actually holds one of the great offices of state?

Wednesday, October 4, 2017

Steve Anglesey rounds up the losers and losers (because there are no winners) of another crazy seven days on Planet Brexit.

Wednesday, October 4, 2017

RICHARD PORRITT with this week's big stories.

Wednesday, October 4, 2017

Now the hype is over, what can we expect next from the king of hygge? As our culture correspondent Viv Groskop reports, it’s time to like lykke.

Wednesday, October 4, 2017

Gin has undergone a remarkable resurgence in popularity in recent years, with many new brands and flavours emerging. There are some older producers, though, with a heritage even stronger than the gin they create.

Wednesday, October 4, 2017

There's good news and bad news for online news publishers: The good is that people are increasingly willing to pay for digital news subscriptions. The bad is that news often takes a back seat to entertainment services like Netflix and Spotify.

Tuesday, October 3, 2017

Peter Trudgill on a remarkable discovery which transformed the way we think about languages.

Tuesday, October 3, 2017

Jack Lang meets the football coach who has eschewed the English game to carve out a career in the dugouts of Latvia.

Tuesday, October 3, 2017

How the 'Flying Finn' dominated distance running during the 1920s through sheer dogged determination more than natural talent.

Podcast

Trending

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter