Regret as Ivan Rogers quits over “muddled thinking” of Brexit plan

13:19 04 January 2017

PA Wire/PA Images

PA Wire/PA Images

PA Wire/PA Images

European Commission expresses regret over shock departure of the EU Ambassador months before Brexit negotiations begin

Brussels officials said the resignation of Sir Ivan Rogers meant the UK had lost a “professional” diplomat who had always “loyally defended” his Government.

In an explosive resignation email, Sir Ivan hit out at the “ill-founded arguments and muddled thinking” of politicians and said civil servants still did not know the Government’s plans for Brexit.

Sir Ivan unexpectedly quit weeks after he sparked controversy by warning the Government that a post-Brexit trade deal could take a decade to finalise, and even then may fail to be ratified by member states.

The European Commission said it regretted the loss of a “very knowledgeable” envoy and indicated that Sir Ivan had been a tough negotiator in wrangles with Brussels.

Sir Simon Fraser, the former head of the Diplomatic Service, warned that Britain was losing one of its biggest experts on Europe months before “very complex” Brexit negotiations begin.

But prominent pro-Brexit MP Iain Duncan Smith suggested civil servants are now having to “tear up the rulebook” for how they normally operate to deal with leaving the EU.

Commission spokeswoman Natasha Bertaud paid tribute to Sir Ivan in Brussels.

She said: “We regret the loss of a very professional, very knowledgeable - while not always easy - interlocutor and diplomat who always loyally defended the interests of his Government.”

Asked if his resignation shortly before the tough Brexit talks begin would cause problems, she said: “This is not something that we are going to comment on at this stage. Negotiations have not yet started and we are still waiting for the triggering of Article 50 to commence those negotiations.”

Sir Simon told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme: “He is a highly intelligent, knowledgeable and experienced official and one of the greatest experts, if I can use the expert word, that we have on European matters in the British Civil Service.”

He went on: “I do think that his sort of in-depth knowledge and expertise is a loss as we go into what is going to be, as (Brexit Secretary) David Davis himself has said, a very complex set of negotiations.”

Sir Simon, who left his post in July 2015, rejected suggestions that Sir Ivan was not tough enough in negotiations, including David Cameron’s attempt to reshape Britain’s relationship with the EU before the referendum.

The ex-diplomat insisted Sir Ivan “called a spade a spade” in his advice to ministers.

In his resignation letter, Sir Ivan criticised politicians and urged his civil servants to continue to challenge ministers and “speak the truth to those in power”.

Sir Ivan wrote: “I hope that you will support each other in those difficult moments where you have to deliver messages that are disagreeable to those who need to hear them.”

It emerged in December, as Theresa May met European counterparts at a Brussels summit, that Sir Ivan had passed on warnings from other EU members that negotiations on a trade deal could take a decade.

But former Tory leader Mr Duncan Smith suggested Sir Ivan’s views were less relevant as EU member states will inevitably be feeding him their most hardline views before negotiations begin.

He told Today: “They are now having to accept and understand that we are leaving and that means therefore sometimes the views and the opinions of what you keep feeding back from various member states isn’t actually sometimes quite relevant.”

Mr Duncan Smith also suggested Sir Ivan had undermined his position by “going public” too often.

Jonathan Powell, Tony Blair’s former chief of staff and an ex-diplomat, warned the Prime Minister against hiring a pro-Brexit successor to Sir Ivan.

Appointing a “patsy” who does not explain plainly what the other side is thinking will doom the Brexit negotiations to failure as ministers will be operating in a “fantasy land” about what is achievable, he told Today.

In the email from Sir Ivan, sent just before 1pm on Tuesday, he said he decided to step down early so his replacement can be in place when Article 50 is triggered by April and formal negotiations begin.

But it comes amid reports of tension between the senior diplomat and ministers because of his pessimistic views on Brexit.

Sir Ivan stressed the need for expert civil servants to play a central role in the negotiations and urged his staff to tell ministers the true opinions of the other 27 member states “even where this is uncomfortable”.

He added: “Serious multilateral negotiating experience is in short supply in Whitehall, and that is not the case in the (European) Commission or in the Council.

“The Government will only achieve the best for the country if it harnesses the best experience we have - a large proportion of which is concentrated in UKREP - and negotiates resolutely.

“Senior ministers, who will decide on our positions, issue by issue, also need from you detailed, unvarnished - even where this is uncomfortable - and nuanced understanding of the views, interests and incentives of the other 27.”

Sir Ivan also said the allocation of roles in the UK’s negotiating team needs “rapid resolution” and hit out at assertions by some politicians that a free trade deal will be easy to negotiate.

In comments seen as a veiled swipe at International Trade Secretary Liam Fox he said: “Contrary to the beliefs of some, free trade does not just happen when it is not thwarted by authorities: increasing market access to other markets and consumer choice in our own, depends on the deals, multilateral, plurilateral and bilateral that we strike, and the terms that we agree.”

Latest articles

The Brex-Factor: 10 of the worst Brexiteers this week

Confused by another week in Brexit? Can’t keep up with all the insanity and inanity coming from 52% Our new weekly chart rates the no-good, the bad and the ugly from the last seven days

What happened to Frexit, Grexit, Nexit and Irexit?

Brexit was meant to light a fire under Europe and spark populist revolts across the continent. In fact, it has united it as never before – and reduced the UK to being the butt of jokes

Football violence : 9 bloodiest battles of European football

Think the north London, Merseyside or even the notorious Old Firm derbies are the pinnacle of footballing rivalries? Europe’s football hooligan clashes will shock you

May and Trump’s special relationship: Brexit will empower the US

The “special relationship” between the US and the UK has long been unbalanced. Brexit will tip the scales completely in favour of the Americans and enfeeble Britain

Populism: lowering of standards let evil in - now we must raise them again

We shouldn’t be surprised about the sudden emergence of populism. Illiberalism has deep roots. And we’ve allowed it to grow

Why are people buying Hitler’s art?

There is a thriving market for paintings by Adolf Hitler. But if the works are not valued for their artistic merit, just what is the attraction?

WIN a fantastic 5 day holiday for 2 to Iceland worth over £1100!

The New European and Newmarket Holidays are offering one lucky competition entrant the chance to discover the wonders of Iceland with a prize worth over £1100!

This is what we learned when Gove met Trump

Are we safe with a pro-Putin, anti-EU, NATO-sceptic in the White House?

Tim Farron: Lib Dems are the only choice for the 48% now

Labour and the Tories are now marching, hand in hand, towards a Hard Brexit

Brexit speech: Britain will sacrifice access to the single market

Britain will pursue a Hard Brexit and quit the European single market when it leaves the EU, Theresa May has confirmed.

The problem with the English: England doesn’t want to be just another member of a team

Brexit is the result of an English delusion, a crisis of identity resulting from a failure to come to terms with the loss of empire and the end of its own exceptionalism, argues Cambridge University professor Nicholas Boyle

Daniel Cohn-Bendit: Democracy is now paying the price for its most precious offering: Freedom

Former leader of the 1968 student protests. Daniel Cohn-Bendit explains what links those protests to Brexit and Trump, where the EU has failed and the simple way it can succeed

Monsieur L’Europe s’inquiète mais le rêve doit persister

Dany Cohn-Bendit est l’Européen par excellence.

Afghan refugees’ empowering, beautiful murals in a Greek refugee camp

These refugees used freedom of expression take back control

Like Meryl, Donald Trump is an actor – Streep gave him her professional opinion

Donald Trump, like Barack Obama before him, is an actor and Meryl Streep played the role of the critic. Playwright Bonnie Greer on an unfolding American drama

Jeremy Corbyn has noble sentiments but a muddy message on Brexit

What Brexit Britain desperately needs is a clear message from the Opposition, but the Labour leadership continues to heap chaos on top of confusion

Alastair Campbell: Corbyn’s Labour is in limbo land over Brexit

Jeremy Corbyn thinks we overdid the control freakery, says Labour’s spin doctor, but he must realise – after that flawed relaunch – that voters need to know exactly what you stand for

Trump scandal generator: Build your own fake news

Whether the allegations are all fake news or not, mix and match by taking one from each column to create your own Trump scandals... quickly, before they actually happen



Newsletter Sign Up