Tory MP’s Hard Brexit warning

PUBLISHED: 11:19 18 March 2017 | UPDATED: 11:19 18 March 2017

PA Wire/PA Images

PA Wire/PA Images

PA Wire/PA Images

Tory MP issues a warning to party colleagues of the dangers of Hard Brexit, as he launches a new initiative to build bridges with Europe

We have heard many calls for what is called a Hard Brexit from our membership of the EU since the EU referendum last June. When pressed on what this means, many eurosceptics seem to relish the idea of tumbling out of our obligations with little regard for the consequences.

Already, in my role as Chair of the Education Select Committee, it is clear the consequences of leaving the EU will have a major impact on our universities. The complexity of unravelling EU relationships and funding in just the higher education sector alone should give pause for thought. That is why I welcome the Government’s recognition that whilst Britain is leaving the EU, it must not turn its back on Europe itself.

In late September 2016, the Education Committee launched an inquiry into the impact of Brexit on higher education – with the clear aim to seek to inform the public and influence the Brexit negotiations.

For this inquiry we ranged out from Westminster and held meetings in Oxford and Newcastle, hearing from university leaders, academics, students and others, as we examined what the Government’s priorities should be for the sector going into the negotiations with the EU.

There are many fears that Britain’s withdrawal from the EU will have a negative impact on higher education. Concerns range from being able to attract the brightest students from across Europe to making sure UK universities maintain their places among the world’s best. We also heard the ramifications for Britons who want to work and study at higher education institutions in the EU.

It’s not just about hard numbers or financial viability though. Sally Hunt, general secretary of the University and College Union, told the Committee that it was naive to think that the sort of rhetoric being used by politicians on immigration does not make its way around the world and have an impact on how we are viewed abroad. She warned that three-quarters of EU academics are thinking of quitting the UK as a result of the referendum, while Professor Michael Arthur, provost of University College London, revealed that applications from EU students across the sector were down more than 7%.

Dr Peter Simpson, director of the N8 Research Partnership of universities across the north of England, said that the loss of research funding would be worse felt outside of London. His group receives around £126 million from EU sources and he said they cannot expect their work to carry on regardless.

The Committee’s findings are expected to be published shortly after the triggering of Article 50 and we want them to influence the negotiations so we don’t face the Hard Brexit which could be so damaging to the working relationships universities have built up across the last four decades in Europe.

As the UK disengages from the EU I believe we must also engage with the next generation of opinion formers, policy makers and academics in remodelling and renewing the Europe in which they will live and work.

The question therefore arises – of how academics, politicians and policy makers can engage with like-minded colleagues from across the UK, Europe and beyond? In Germany, there are eleven organisations for the promotion of young talents (Begabtenförderwerke), institutes affiliated to the major parties and funded by the taxpayer, which ensure that the politics of the Federal Republic are widely understood amongst current and future leaders in other democratic nations. There has never been an equivalent initiative here, nor is there any immediate prospect of one.

To fill this vacuum I have founded Modern Europe. This is a new kind of organisation, specifically tailored to promote the UK’s influence and international relationships, and to ensure that policy makers and politicians have opportunities to learn from their peers in the many other democratic nations.

The organisation is not party political and it will operate resolutely and clearly in the public interest and in the political mainstream, promoting international dialogue. It is very much modelled upon the work carried out by the Konrad Adenauer Stiftung (KAS) and others in Germany.

We run a specific academic and student outreach programme to enable those studying international relations and politics to participate in an exchange of ideas about the challenges facing Europe in the decade ahead. The first seminar in our student programme will be held jointly with the KAS in London, bringing together German students studying in the UK with UK students.

Modern Europe understands we are leaving the EU, but recognises an important reality: “We cannot turn our backs on Europe – we are part of Europe.” Another generation will want to forge their own relationships with our friends and therefore no bridges should be burnt.

Neil Carmichael is Conservative MP for Stroud and chair of the Education Select Committee since 2015. He is also chair of the Conservative Group for Europe and founder of Modern Europe. For more information, visit

Support The New European's vital role as a voice for the 48%

The New European is proud of its journalism and we hope you are proud of it too. We believe our voice is important - both in representing the pro-EU perspective and also to help rebalance the right wing extremes of much of the UK national press. If you value what we are doing, you can help us by making a contribution to the cost of our journalism.

  • Become a Friend of The New European for a contribution of £48. You will qualify for a mention in our newspaper (should you wish).
  • Become a Patron of The New European for a contribution of £480. You or your company will be mentioned in the newspaper each week (should you wish) and you and a guest will be invited to join the editor at a special lunch in London this June to discuss the anniversary of Brexit.

Supporter Options

Mention Me in The New European

Latest articles

The choice is simple – vote down extremists, dreamers and chancers

Is it time for toughness to discourage further defections or for accommodation to a changing public mood across the Union?

Question Time Live: Political debate from Oxford ahead of the election

All the action from Question Time as Britain gears up for the Brexit Election.

Britain on collision course with Europe over Brexit bill

Angela Merkel has said the UK has “illusions” about the realities of Brexit and insisted talks on the UK’s divorce bill from the EU must be dealt with before trade negotiations can begin.

Election Live: Boris clatters into campaign mode and Labour on housing

All the news, updates and reactino on April 27.

Election Live: Final PMQs and parties square up over NHS

All the news, reaction and updates on April 26.

Here’s how the Remain cause has ceased to be the establishment

When you think about it, Theresa May’s decision to call a snap election should come as no surprise.

Fear is mounting that Brexit’s impact will spill across the Irish Sea

With the clock ticking not only on Article 50, but also a UK general election, is Ireland the part of Europe with most to fear from Brexit’s fallout?

Danger ahead: Could Mrs May’s Brexit Election come back to bite her?

The Prime Minister believes she holds all the cards as the country embarks on a General Election. But Labour could still spring a surprise at the ballot box

Is Tim Farron the man with the most to gain from this election?

The Liberal Democrat leader is the one Number 10 increasingly fears

Starmer vows MPs could veto Brexit under Labour

MPs would be given the chance to halt a Brexit deal secured by a Labour government, Shadow Brexit Secretary Keir Starmer has said.

Election Live: Starmer spells out Labour’s Brexit strategy

All the election news, reaction and updates on April 25.

France and the long shadow of Putin

One of France’s most powerful political figures wasn’t on the ballot paper – he was more than 1,500 miles away, at home in the Kremlin

ELECTION LIVE: Tories attack Corbyn on defence, Lib Dem members boost

All the updates, reaction and analysis on Monday April 24.

Labour needs a Brexit strategy, not just ideology

Labour could still shock Theresa May at the ballot box. But Corbyn needs to up his game on Brexit

FRENCH ELECTION: Far-right candidate Le Pen makes it in to final two

Pro-EU centrist Emmanuel Macron will face far-right Marine Le Pen in a head-to-head battle for the French presidency.

Turkey, Brexit and the danger of referendums: A recipe for division

Brexit raises more and more questions for its backers. Yet they still have no answers

ELECTION LIVE: Corbyn’s new bank holidays and Farron gay row grows

Follow all the developments and reactions on Sunday April 23.

Here’s why May’s election won’t pan out according to plan...

... they never do, says The New European’s election editor

ELECTION LIVE: Candidates hit the streets as ground war kicks off

Live election coverage including news, reaction and analysis on Saturday April 22.


Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter