Unmasking the guilty men (and one woman) of Brexit

PUBLISHED: 12:04 11 July 2017

"Britain needs not only a change of policy but a complete purification"

Archant

Shortly after the outbreak of WW2, a polemic was published identifying the “guilty men” who had led Britain to such a moment of weakness and peril. Now, following Brexit, a new version has been released.

It’s a curious case of the dog that didn’t bark. Not only was it silent during the entire Brexit referendum campaign; not a whimper was heard from it before, and it has remained docile ever since.

I mean the UK’s membership of NATO. Very curious indeed, because NATO membership involves a pooling of sovereignty as great as – in many ways more than – membership of the EU. There is the integrated command structure, which was too much for de Gaulle. And the unqualified commitment to mutual defence in Article 5, which is precisely the obligation to intervene in “a quarrel in a far-away country between people of whom we know nothing“ which Neville Chamberlain baulked at in the Munich crisis of 1938.

This is no weak or hypothetical pledge. At this moment NATO troops, with a substantial British contingent, are exercising in the far-away Baltic states, by their Russian borders, where tensions are high. Putin has already invaded one sovereign neighbour and is massing on the borders of others. Yet as Britain turns ever more inwards in its aversion to “Europe”, NATO never features in the debate. Tellingly, NATO makes not a single appearance in this magisterial denunciation by “Cato the Younger” of the “guilty men” responsible for Brexit.

Why does exiting the European Union not mean exiting from NATO? And how does one explain the contradiction between wanting to “take back control” from Brussels while being all too willing to subordinate control of our defence capability to – of all people – Donald Trump?

This is a question barely asked in the debate on Brexit, yet it is begged by Cato because his indictment of the “guilty men of Brexit” is modelled on his grandfather’s (or rather, Michael Foot’s) denunciation of the “guilty men of Munich” published in 1940. The one thing that the Brexiteers have not put in immediate danger is the military defence of the realm; indeed, the most hawkish Brexiteers are also mostly the most hawkish defence-mongers. Farage, with his love of Putin, is an exception; but his Russophilia does not extend to a scintilla of criticism of the NATO or the Atlantic alliance under the leadership of his friend Trump. I think the apparent contradiction is the explanation, or at least a good part of it.

Because when Remainers argue that Britain is endangered by leaving “Europe”, in truth Britain is only partly leaving Europe – the economic part, not the defence part. The bedrock of NATO and the Atlantic alliance means that the Brexiteers are never endangering the UK in the sense of putting the defence of the realm in immediate peril. On the contrary, they argue that Britain’s importance to European “security” – a word they use a lot, without any hint that it goes alongside significant pooling of sovereignty – will ultimately oblige France and Germany to come to a decent deal on Brexit.

This, in turn, goes to the heart of a problem and peculiarity of the EU, dating back to its foundation – its lack of a defence component, which makes it almost unique among confederations. Most such entities are either founded on defence and foreign policy unions or rapidly forge them, as with the American colonies. The EU was founded as an economic union, and apart from a few fitful forays into the security space, it has never sought to usurp NATO as a defence union. Hence George Washington is the founder of the US; Jean Monnet, an economic technocrat, the EU.

The politics of the late 1940s and 1950s, and the continuing US commitment to European defence, largely explain this peculiarity. Attempts at forging a Franco-German defence union, supported in the early post-war years by the US, foundered on de Gaulle’s refusal to participate. Britain’s policy of standing apart from the emerging EU while remaining at the heart of NATO exacerbated the bifurcation. Had Europe followed Churchill’s advice (when he was in opposition to Attlee) and formed a genuine “United States”, and had Britain been in the lead, then such a union might have started with defence and foreign policy, not with coal and steel. But it was not to be.

The bifurcation has been bad for Britain and bad for Europe. For Britain, it has encouraged delusions of international grandeur, founded on a weak economy, reaching the most absurd level of posturing in Liam Fox and David Davis’s latest quest for “Empire 2.0”, founded on a post-imperial “Commonwealth” which now accounts for a tiny fraction of our trade and even less of our defence capability. For the Continental Europeans, conversely, the British and American nuclear and defence umbrella have excused all but cursory engagement in serious defence capability, with the exception of France which manages to stand proudly aloof from much of NATO and therefore fails to act as a reliable bridge.

To the extent that it remains at the heart of NATO, Britain has learnt from the “Men of Munich”, as Cato demonstrates with poignant historical resonance. But how does Britain learn from the mistakes of the post-war era – a weak economy outside London and the south-east, and woefully underskilled workforce, which believes that the world owes it a living because of its past glory and continuing military presence?

Not with the leaders who got us into this mess. Cato excoriates the men (plus one woman) involved, and simply to list the names – Thatcher, Dacre, Murdoch, Tebbit, Farage, Johnson – is to summon up a house of horrors when allied to the word “Europe”.

David Cameron is a special case. He was in some ways the most responsible, with his disastrous decision to call the in/out referendum; yet his policy of trying to hold the ring between competing factions within a long-running Tory civil war essentially continued the policy and strategy of John Major, the previous Tory prime minister, and it had worked then. Like Chamberlain and Major, he was a decent man in indecent times.

More debatable is Cato’s indictment of pretty well the entire European elite of the past generation, including Mitterrand, Kohl and Merkel, for proceeding too rapidly with EU integration and failing (in Merkel’s case) to do enough to appease Britain. I find these among the accused “not guilty”. It is hard enough, as a political leader, to run your own country effectively, and do your bit for the international common weal. I don’t think you can reasonably be expected to run another one too, when that country is Britain – an international and democratic adult which ought to behave like one.

But one’s verdict does not affect the brilliance of the prosecution, and I cannot recommend Cato’s Guilty Men too highly for an understanding of our present discontents. His – or is it her? – denunciation of the individuals is excelled only by a contempt for the “sins” of the Brexiteers: deceit, distortion, personal gain, failures of leadership, gloating, hubris, and frivolity. In Cato’s baleful eye, Britain needs not only a change of policy but a complete purification. Let’s hope it is not too painful.

Lord Adonis is chairman of the National Infrastructure Commission. He served in the Labour governments of Tony Blair and Gordon Brown, holding posts including Transport Secretary and Schools Minister

Guilty Men, by ‘Cato the Younger’, is published by Biteback

Support The New European's vital role as a voice for the 48%

The New European is proud of its journalism and we hope you are proud of it too. We believe our voice is important - both in representing the pro-EU perspective and also to help rebalance the right wing extremes of much of the UK national press. If you value what we are doing, you can help us by making a contribution to the cost of our journalism.

  • Become a friend of The New European for a contribution of £48. You will qualify for a mention in our newspaper (should you wish)
  • Become a partner of The New European for a contribution of £240. You will qualify for a mention in our newspaper (should you wish) and receive a New European Branded Pen and Notebook
  • Become a patron of The New European for a contribution of £480. You will qualify for a mention in our newspaper (should you wish) and receive a New European Branded Pen and Notebook and an A3 print of The New European front cover of your choice, signed by Editor Matt Kelly

By proceeding, you agree to the New Europeans supporters club Terms & Conditions which can be found here.



Supporter Options

Mention Me in The New European



If Yes, Name to appear in The New European



Latest Articles

Wednesday, September 20, 2017

We have a number of set phrases in English which we use in a rather automatic and semi-obligatory way at particular times and in specific social situations – such as ‘good morning’ and ‘good evening’, ‘happy birthday’ and ‘happy new year’.

Wednesday, September 20, 2017

Scotland's three biggest parties have all experienced sudden jolts in recent weeks. MAURICE SMITH reports on the tectonic plates shifting once again north of the border

Wednesday, September 20, 2017

The Lib Dems have stepped back from the Brexit cliff-edge.

Wednesday, September 20, 2017

A fitting 48 times the hapless foreign secretary, currently backtracking from his bungled attempt to topple Theresa May, outraged with his thoughtless comments and ill-judged actions

Wednesday, September 20, 2017

Despite its devastating impact, Hurricane Irma passed with only a handful of deaths yet received wall-to-wall media coverage. On the other side of the world, floods have left a far higher death toll, yet reporting has been sparse. LIZ GERARD asks what is behind this apparent hypocrisy and what it says about us

Monday, September 18, 2017

Sir Vince Cable is to set out his bid to scupper Brexit by declaring “I am a proud saboteur”.

Monday, September 18, 2017

Imagine a town studded with watchtowers like San Gimignano in Tuscany, but set high on a plateau, 100 miles from the nearest centre of population.

Monday, September 18, 2017

A top Brexit Whitehall official has been moved out of the Department for Exiting the EU amid rumours of a rift with David Davis.

Monday, September 18, 2017

The venerable Dr Johnson described patriotism as “the last refuge of the scoundrel”.

Monday, September 18, 2017

It might not have grabbed the world's attention yet but, says AURORA TORRES, the over-exploitation of sand is a looming crisis for the globe, causing environmental destruction, putting communities at risk and sparking illegal black markets

Monday, September 18, 2017

The lights are going out in comments sections all over the world.

Sunday, September 17, 2017

Home Secretary Amber Rudd today accused her Cabinet colleague Boris Johnson of "back-seat driving" as the row over his Brexit intervention deepened.

Monday, September 18, 2017

I couldn’t make it to the March For Europe last Saturday; perhaps this dereliction of duty means my Remoaner licence has now been revoked and I must now be demoted to Regrumbler or Rewhiner.

Monday, September 18, 2017

Angela Merkel may be on course for victory but her campaign for the German chancellorship is not the stately procession it might seem from afar. TONY PATERSON joins her on a decidedly bumpy election trail

Monday, September 18, 2017

Thousands of anti-Donald Trump posters inspired by Second World War public information designs have been plastered across Washington DC.

Friday, September 15, 2017

“Trees are sanctuaries,” wrote the German author and poet Hermann Hesse. “Whoever knows how to speak to them, whoever knows how to listen to them, can learn the truth.”

Friday, September 15, 2017

BONNIE GREER on the conviction that you can have your cake and eat it

Thursday, September 14, 2017

A legitimisation of radical right-wing ideology is taking place around the world. The world was shocked by the events in Charlottesville, America, and by Donald Trump’s failure to condemn racist violence.

Wednesday, September 13, 2017

RICHARD PORRITT with the week's big stories

Wednesday, September 13, 2017

Mancunian musician Mark Reeder arrived in Berlin in 1979 and never looked back.

Wednesday, September 13, 2017

Britain will "soon regret" leaving the EU, European Commission president Jean-Claude Juncker has warned in his annual state of the union speech.

Tuesday, September 12, 2017

Right, so where are we now then?

Tuesday, September 12, 2017

Donald Trump and Kim Jong-Un are playing a very dangerous game of nuclear poker, argues Paul Connew. But does either leader have the cards that could avoid destruction?

Monday, September 11, 2017

When Muslim feminist SEYRAN ATES opened a liberal mosque in Berlin this summer she was met with a barrage of death threats and fatwas. But she says she is undeterred in her campaign to use enlightenment values to defeat extremism – in all forms

Monday, September 11, 2017

Many of the materials we use derive their names from the towns they were first made in. PETER TRUDGILL explores the stories behind some of the best-known

Monday, September 11, 2017

Theresa May’s insistence that she is sticking around as PM may have been met with scepticism and incredulity, but PR agent MARK BORKOWSKI argues her reboot may yet work

Monday, September 11, 2017

His stricken condition fuels macabre speculation, but Michael Schumacher’s real legacy is the remarkable run of Grand Prix dominance which began 25 years ago. ROB BURNETT reports

Friday, September 8, 2017

Writer, April 17, 1885 - September 7, 1962

Friday, September 8, 2017

For comedian MITCH BENN, Theresa May’s attempts to extend her political life put him in mind of his favourite film, Blade Runner. Here, he goes on the trail of Downing Street’s replicant

Sunday, September 10, 2017

An estimated 50,000 passionate Remainers marched on Parliament yesterday demanding the Government reverse its Brexit strategy.

Sunday, September 10, 2017

Tony Blair today made an explosive intervention in the Brexit debate, calling for tough new immigration rules which would allow Britain to stay in the EU.

Monday, September 11, 2017

British identity is fragmented like never before, with the rise of pop-up populism dividing people into “them” and “us”. Author PETER POMERANTSEV takes a deeply personal journey through Britain to find out what it means for the country

Friday, September 8, 2017

A refusal to confront its past leaves France facing an uncertain future, argues MARTIN EVANS

Friday, September 8, 2017

Al Jazeera may have its flaws, but its persecution is seriously bad news for the world, says PAUL KNOTT

Friday, September 8, 2017

If you’re looking for a phrase to describe the change in newspaper print circulations this year, it might well be “the bigger they are, the harder they fall”. The latest figures from the Audit Bureau of Circulation (ABC) demonstrate that only the Metro managed to increase its print circulation year-on-year, with every single other national title recording a fall.

Friday, September 8, 2017

It’s not just back to school for the nation’s children, this week, but also for politicians and British business.

Friday, September 8, 2017

Modern Germany has a very different political and media culture to our own, and some of that was on display in Sunday’s ‘TV-Duell’ between Chancellor Angela Merkel and her SDP challenger Martin Schulz.

Thursday, September 7, 2017

STEVE ANGLESEY picks out the worst Brexiteers of the week

Thursday, September 7, 2017

RICHARD PORRITT on the week's big stories

Thursday, September 7, 2017

Britain's chances of being ready to begin EU trade negotiations by the next round of trade talks in October are "in the neighbourhood of zero", former European Council president Herman van Rompuy warned today.

Podcast

Trending

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter