Video
Former Tory minister claims cost of coronavirus lockdown outweighed the benefits
Baroness Neville-Rolfe in the House of Lords. Photograph: House of Lords. - Credit: Archant
A former Tory minister has questioned the economic cost of the coronavirus lockdown - claiming the cost outweighed the benefits.
Baroness Neville-Rolfe, who served as a business minister under Theresa May and was once a Tesco executive, challenged the government to outline what plans they had to ensure that fuller account was taken of the economic costs of any measures adopted to tackle the pandemic such as lockdowns.
Baroness Penn, responding on behalf of the government, pointed out the lockdown had been about protecting lives and controlling the virus.
She added that the government had provided unprecedented package of economic support, and was planning a 'phased approach' to re-opening the economy to minimise the risk of a second peak of the virus.
Lady Neville-Rolfe said she welcomed the package of support, but said the UK experience in recent months showed 'the costs of severe restrictions imposed for medical reasons are large and indeed much larger than the benefits'.
You may also want to watch:
She cited a paper entitled Living with Covid-19: balancing costs against benefits in the face of the virus which she said made a strong case that the recent lifting of lockdown restrictions had been justified and measures to counter any flare-up should be 'carefully targeted, rather than general'.
Lady Penn said she was absolutely right and ministers wanted to use 'all the tools available to us to implement a targeted response to any local outbreaks'.
Most Read
- 1 Piers Morgan and Susanna Reid reject Boris Johnson's coronavirus claim
- 2 Sky News presenter says Boris Johnson is 'gaslighting the nation' over Covid claims
- 3 Nigel Farage reminded of claim that 'acid test of Brexit' surrounds fishing after clip resurfaces
- 4 Pro-Brexit fishing campaigner says Boris Johnson's deal has left her with 'no fish'
- 5 Home Office launches voluntary repatriation scheme for EU nationals
- 6 PMQs: Boris Johnson calls for apology from Keir Starmer over coronavirus stances
- 7 Jeremy Corbyn loses bid to release Labour documents ahead of High Court battle
- 8 Brussels politician says Boris Johnson should 'pay for EU workers to stay' in UK
- 9 Boris Johnson is the 'worst PM' and should resign, says Alastair Campbell
- 10 European parliament agrees to add British overseas territories to post-Brexit tax haven blacklist
She said the government would use the test and trace system to work with local authorities to contain the virus.
'National measures do remain a tool available to us but they are not one that we would want to use again,' Lady Penn added.
Last month an expert claims that the coronavirus death toll could have been halved if the lockdown was introduced a week earlier.
Become a Supporter
The New European is proud of its journalism and we hope you are proud of it too. We believe our voice is important - both in representing the pro-EU perspective and also to help rebalance the right wing extremes of much of the UK national press. If you value what we are doing, you can help us by making a contribution to the cost of our journalism.
