ANDREW ADONIS: Dominic Cummings is intent on jeopardising our entire political system
- Credit: PA Wire/PA Images
Why the new 'joint prime minister''s fascination with Bismarck isn't just weird - it's dangerous for Britain.
Now Dominic Cummings is joint prime minister, we have to take him seriously as more than a Vote Leave operative. I have therefore been reading all his interminable blogs on Bismarck, eugenics and American fighter pilots. I thought they'd be weird. Actually they are dangerous.
The weird bits are the obsession with physical combat and IQ. This explains his wild pugilism. And why Michael Gove, the first of Cummings's minister-pupils, did so much to wreck England's schools by decreeing that fewer and fewer teenagers should pass more and more exams. Cummings now plans to 'Darwin-ise' the nation, not just the education system. Enter Prince Bismarck, founding chancellor of the Second Reich.
It is hard to conceive a more dangerous inspiration. Bismarck's motto was 'blood and iron.' He hated not just socialists and the French but liberalism and European co-operation on any basis of human rights and conciliation. He believed in master and inferior races, the inferior being all but the Prussians, and distrusted Germany's churches for their ethics and alternative authority. He disliked Britain as a hotbed of 'parliamentaryism' and as an unreliable ally for reactionary conservatism.
Cummings laps all this up. Far from excusing Bismarck's excesses, he applies them to Brexit Britain. Bismarck's one saving grace - his schemes of social insurance, intended to forestall the social democrats - is unmentioned by Cummings since it sits so uneasily with the Brexit project to, in Lord Lawson's words, "complete the Thatcher revolution".
You may also want to watch:
Tellingly also, Cummings never mentions Bismarck's liberal contemporary, William Ewart Gladstone, who propelled Britain and much of non-German Europe towards democracy and self-government. The 'People's William' championed constitutional liberalism, which he sound-bited as "trust in the people tempered by prudence", in opposition to Bismarckian conservatism of distrust of the people tempered by fear.
Bismarck's currency was fear and conquest to the absolute limits of a modern state - to Cummings' approval and the approval of you-know-who, who founded the Third Reich and ardently admired his predecessor of only 43 years.
- 1 Brexiteer Prue Leith quits Tory Party after government votes down motion to protect UK food standards
- 2 Piers Morgan must expose the government's Brexit betrayal
- 3 Public slams Brexit Party tweet which shames Tory MPs who voted against free school meals
- 4 Peers set to remove law-breaking sections of Boris Johnson's Brexit bill
- 5 Group in protest against Tory MPs who voted down free school meals targets offices with empty plates
- 6 Tory minister blames journalists for NHS Test and Trace failure as he defends Dido Harding
- 7 Michel Barnier postpones Brussels return as Brexit trade talks in London continue
- 8 James Cleverly mocked after telling people to 'look at how they're doing in Wales'
- 9 Dido Harding is struggling to defend the indefensible
- 10 UKIP set to select 'Dr Gammons' as candidate for London mayoral election
"Politics," said Bismarck, "is like visiting a country one does not know with people whom one does not know and whose reactions one cannot predict. When one person puts a hand in his pocket, the other person is already drawing his gun, and when he pulls the trigger the first one fires and it is too late then to ask whether the requirements of common law with regard to self-defence apply."
In this world of shoot or be shot, there is little scope for institutions based on deliberation, cooperation and conciliation, nationally or internationally. Bismarck never reconciled himself to parliamentary politics - at which Gladstone was master, creating Britain's modern parliamentary system. His rule was an extension of the power of the Prussian Kaiser, rebranded Emperor of Germany after unification. When he eventually resigned in 1890 it was because he fell out with the erratic Kaiser Wilhelm II.
Cummings quotes approvingly Bismarck's view that "as soon as parliamentary representatives assemble, they are dumb in the mass" and praises China for its ability to "erect skyscrapers in weeks while parliament delays Heathrow expansion for over a decade". How hackneyed. Parliament last year voted by ten-to-one to expand Heathrow, and modern London is full of skyscrapers. Surprise, surprise, Cummings is already scheming to override parliament and this week "spat out his drink laughing" when it was suggested that parliament could force Johnson (and him) to resign if they attempt to force through no-deal.
Bismarck's memorial in Berlin depicts him wielding a sword, surrounded by statues of Atlas, Siegfried and Germania. Gladstone's statue on the Strand is encircled by Brotherhood, Aspiration, Education and Courage. I know which I prefer, and which is better for Britain and Europe.
Become a Supporter
The New European is proud of its journalism and we hope you are proud of it too. We believe our voice is important - both in representing the pro-EU perspective and also to help rebalance the right wing extremes of much of the UK national press. If you value what we are doing, you can help us by making a contribution to the cost of our journalism.