Letter: Why the Irish referendum counts
PUBLISHED: 13:23 04 June 2018 | UPDATED: 13:23 04 June 2018
PA Wire/PA Images
Referendums are best when the issue being voted upon is a narrow one where the pro and anti arguments can be easily explained on the back of an envelope. Sarah Austin explains more.
I hoped for the result in Ireland but didn’t expect it. What I should have expected is the queue of Brexiteers (mostly men) on social media asking if we have suddenly changed our tune on referendums.
The answer is simple. Referendums are best when the issue being voted upon is a narrow one where the pro and anti arguments can be easily explained on the back of an envelope.
Referendums are at their worst when the issue is hugely complex, where a binary yes/no choice is imposed nonetheless and especially where no-one can agree on what the yes/no binary choice actually means (Michael Gove etc can protest as much as they like about what their campaign said, but polls show most Leave voters did not expect to leave the single market).
I should add also that the Irish ‘no’ campaign was not based on a single lie emblazoned on a big red bus, nor was a rebel ‘no’ campaign given huge media coverage for distasteful and disingenuous campaign posters.
• Send your letters for publication to email@example.com