Commons speaker Lindsay Hoyle tells Boris Johnson not to ‘shy away’ from parliamentary scrutiny

Sir Lindsay said he is ‘perplexed’ when ministers make statements in Downing Street that could have been delivered in the chamber, as he urged the government to ‘put the House first’.

The speaker said MPs were the ‘right people’ to scrutinise ministers, and took aim at announcements made at the daily coronavirus press conferences.

Have your say
Send your letters for publication to The New European by emailing letters@theneweuropean.co.uk and pick up an edition each Thursday for more comment and analysis. Find your nearest stockist here or subscribe to a print or digital edition for just £13. You can also join our readers' Facebook group to keep the discussion and debate going with thousands of fellow pro-Europeans.

The ministerial code states that ‘the most important announcements of government policy should be made in the first instance, in parliament’ when it is sitting.

Asked if he believes Johnson and his government respect parliament, the speaker told the PA News Agency: ‘They’re elected to parliament.

‘I think we’ve always got to remind people: you may be the prime minister but you have a constituency that elects the MP to this House, and he is no different.

‘He may be the prime minister but he is still a member of parliament.

‘What I would say is the House should know first, I’m very clear on that, and I do get perplexed when we see a statement being made in Downing Street that could have been made in the House.

‘The House should hear it first.

‘I’m very clear on that, I’m very strong on that message.

‘And I will continue to ensure that that message is being driven into Downing Street if they don’t play and do the right thing by the House.

‘Because in the end it’s not about what I think, it’s also about the MPs that have got to hold that government to account.

‘Even his own backbenchers want to hear it first, they don’t want to hear it through the BBC or Sky News, they want to hear it on the floor of the House.

‘Because in the end Sky News and the BBC can pick it up from the chamber.

‘So what I always say to the prime minister is ‘please, I know we’re in recess so now I will accept statements to be made and that’s fine’, but when the House comes back, the House shall hear it first.

‘It’s a very clear message to the prime minister and the government: put the House first.’

Asked why he thought ministers were making announcements to the press, he said: ‘I think it’s about trying to get the right time for the news… there are these key slot times that they try to work to.

He joked that ‘maybe we ought to get the House to start sitting (in time for the news)’, but said: ‘The key time is the House… you’re elected to the House, and the House shall hear it first.’

Sir Lindsay added: ‘Boris Johnson shouldn’t shy away from the House, far from it, he is a showman, enjoy your ring, it is your circus.’

The speaker said that there seems to be a ‘pecking order’ deciding which journalists get questions at the Downing Street briefings, but that ‘you can’t do that in parliament because I’m deciding who is going to ask the question’.

‘So I put more scrutiny into it and that’s what it’s about.

‘I know that journalists have got a great job to do and I’m very proud but what journalists do is also holding the government to account.

‘But in fairness the journalists can watch the right people scrutinising the statements and then you can get your news stories from that.’

Hoyle also said that former Commons speaker Baroness Betty Boothroyd ‘gets me put in my place’ with regular phone calls telling him whether he is getting things right or wrong, and encouraging him to ‘tell him (the prime minister) straight’.