Skip to main content

Hello. It looks like you’re using an ad blocker that may prevent our website from working properly. To receive the best experience possible, please make sure any ad blockers are switched off, or add to your trusted sites, and refresh the page.

If you have any questions or need help you can email us.

Is America doomed?

Some say the US is in a superpower death spiral like the one that hit post-empire Britain. The signs of decline are there – but so are some green shoots

The final scene from the 1968 film Planet of the Apes

On August 16 it will be a year since Joe Biden signed into law one of the most consequential pieces of US legislation in decades – the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA). And now, despite the incessant dirge of declinism, America appears to be in reasonably good nick.

There is still some bumpiness. In early August, the US economy’s health was downgraded from “AAA” to “AA+” by ratings agency Fitch, much to the fury of Democrats, and inflation has just ticked up to 3.2%, rising for the first time in 13 months. The country continues to carry a huge amount of debt – $32tn (£25.2tn), equivalent to 128% of GDP.

But while the president remains unpopular, “Bidenomics”, the term the White House is using to describe the great reset, appears to be unleashing investors’ animal spirits. Billions of dollars are rolling into manufacturing, infrastructure and green innovation. As of April, spending on new factories was tracking at three times the $63bn annual rate customary in the 2010s. 

In July, the US unemployment rate had been less than 4% for 17 straight months, the longest such stretch since the 1970s. In June, when inflation fell to a two-year low of 3%, wages rose by an average of 4.4%, meaning that American workers’ real buying power had increased. 

Internationally, the US dollar overwhelmingly retains what a 1960s French finance minister sneeringly called its ”exorbitant privilege” as the world’s reserve currency. The dollar’s closest competitor is the Chinese yuan. In the last decade, the yuan’s share of global payments doubled – to a measly 3%. The dollar is at roughly 60% despite muttered speculation on the issue, from Russia to Africa to the Middle East.

Look across the pond and Britain, America’s predecessor as an Anglophone global hegemon, is in dire straits, some 75 years after its imperial assets started to be stripped away. In July, the UK was the only major economy saddled with rising inflation, according to the OECD. Britain remains short of one million workers – most of the unfilled jobs being in essential sectors such as construction, retail and agriculture – and it is stuck in the slough of low productivity. 

As one US analyst has noted, it’s the UK, Italy and Japan, not America, that seem in danger of becoming “undeveloping” countries, with stagnation shading into decline.

And yet some still insist that the USA is on the same downward spiral that unmade British power in the 20th century. From Europe to Asia to Oceania, there are doubts about the strength and direction of American democracy, the scale of America’s influence, and the solidity of transatlantic and transpacific partnerships. There is concern about the extent to which US growth now depends on deficits and debt. There is dismay about the direction of a country that allows states to ban abortion while refusing to intervene against a gun culture that has produced 27 mass killings in the first six months of the year; America’s deadliest period since 2006. 

And, of course, there is the fact that 55% of Americans consider that Biden is doing a bad job, potentially leaving the door to the White House open for a racist, sexist bully who was twice impeached and now has three criminal indictments. Were America to have a second Donald Trump presidency, it could be curtains for old alliances, the US commitment to Nato and to climate change initiatives.

Funnily enough, the declinists have long been in the ascendancy – even when there was no Trump on the political scene and America was emphatically not in decline. For much of what TIME magazine’s publisher, Henry Luce, christened “the American century”, American declinism was both cottage industry and big business.

Since the mid-1950s, when the US became the world’s dominant power, American declinism has been a passionate subject of intellectual and policy debate. In the 60s, there was Challenge to Affluence, a book by Gunnar Myrdal, economist and future Nobel laureate. It warned that the US was suffering from “relative economic stagnation” and needed to drastically change course if it were not to fall behind the Soviet Union. In the 70s, there was The End of the American Era by political scientist Andrew Hacker, which declared that the US was “no longer capable of being a great power”. In the 80s, Harvard Business School professor George Cabot Lodge II wrote The American Disease, which drew unfavourable parallels with the post-imperial British economy’s loss of competitiveness. 

And then came British historian and Yale professor Paul Kennedy’s 1987 international bestseller, The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers. It looked briefly at empires prior to 1500, then focused on once-dominant powers of the next five centuries – Habsburg Spain, Bourbon France, the British empire – and finished by analysing trends that revealed, Kennedy said, the US in relative decline after a 40-year period of unusual supremacy. The decline would occur, he said, partly because of “imperial overstretch” as well as the rise of the rest, notably Japan. Paraphrasing George Bernard Shaw, Kennedy wrote in reference to the richest town on the US east coast: “Rome fell; Babylon fell; Scarsdale’s turn will come.”

With hindsight, the late 20th century’s persistent narrative of decline can be interpreted as fear – that America’s good fortune could not possibly last and its luck must inevitably run out. In the noughties and teens of this century, declinism has remained a constant drumbeat, rising to fever pitch in the post-Trump era. 

The difference now is that the declinism charge is about facts, not just fear.

The US federal government continues to be plagued by extreme political partisanship, and for all that admiring books are being written about the IRA remaking the world’s green industrial policy, it cleared the Senate only by a backdoor special process called reconciliation. That was a way to bypass the dreaded filibuster, an archaic manoeuvre that is not in the US Constitution but has become a part of the federal legislature’s byzantine rules, requiring supermajority approvals for even the most ordinary legislation and rendering gridlock almost endemic to the American system. As Barack Obama once noted, “If I sponsor a bill declaring apple pie American, it might fall victim to partisan politics”.

Then there are the ongoing attempts by Republicans at federal and state level to enact anti-democratic, almost anti-people legislation to suppress voting by minority groups more likely to vote for the Democrats. With the US unable to manage that sine qua non of a democracy – the peaceful transfer of power – in its last presidential election, it now faces the challenge of avoiding a repeat, possibly more decisive and dangerous showdown in 2024.

Meanwhile, political polarisation is demonstrably altering Americans’ perception of truth and lies. One year into Biden’s presidency, a national poll showed that more than 40% of Americans still didn’t believe or weren’t sure he legitimately won the 2020 election even though there was no evidence of widespread voter fraud.

Add to that the usual laundry list of creeping decrepitude – an under-resourced education system in the centre of the culture wars, rising wealth inequality, the hollowing out of the middle class and the influence of money and special interests in a never-ending election cycle. 

As William Safire trenchantly noted in the closing months of the presidency of the first George Bush, “the ouching outcasts of outrage” are in full cry, and they’re complaining “that it’s late afternoon in America”. But that was in 1992. Right now, it feels closer to midnight in the United States. This time, American declinism seems real. Is it?

Yes and no. The idea of certain decline should be tested against recent examples of American political even-handedness, cohesion and resilience. Consider this: first, in an August 8 special election, conservative-leaning Ohio became the fourth red state – after Kansas, Kentucky and Montana – to vote in favour of a more nuanced view of abortion rights than the bans and restrictions advocated by those who argue that it amounts to a licence to criminally and casually end human life. Ohio’s vote went against the prescriptions of its anti-abortion Republican-controlled legislature. It came 14 months after the Supreme Court overturned Roe v Wade, thereby ending the constitutional right to abortion in the United States. 

Ohio’s decision took some of what Americans call spunk. In the wake of the Supreme Court decision, the Ohio legislature had already passed some of America’s strictest curbs on abortion, banning the procedure as early as six weeks into pregnancy. Unsurprisingly, the Ohio election came to be seen as a broader proxy battle. On one side was a proposed amendment to the state constitution guaranteeing abortion rights, which will now be on the state ballot in November. On the other was the issue of how voters in Republican-voting or Republican-leaning states would view sensitive issues such as women having legal control over reproductive decisions and doctors’ ability to make medical judgments (sans criminal liability) on the need for abortions.

That said, it’s important to be clear what really happened in Ohio and what it might mean. Like much of America, Ohio is not overwhelmingly in favour of abortion, but not overwhelmingly in favour either of banning the right to choose. The end result of its special election indicated a more benign centrism, a willingness to embrace a middle-of-the-road framework that works for almost everyone. Just like in Kansas in August 2022, the first US state to vote on abortion rights since the Supreme Court ruling.

 Kansas voters rejected a proposed state constitutional amendment that would have said there was no right to an abortion in the state. Three months later, conservative Kentucky and ruby-red Montana also voted overwhelmingly in support of carving out exceptions for women who seek abortions.

Move over to Wisconsin in America’s upper Midwest, and the issue of balance on reproductive rights saw voters electing a liberal judge to the state supreme court in April by a remarkable margin of 11 percentage points.

Second, on August 9, a young survivor of one of America’s many horrific school shootings launched a political action committee (PAC) to fundraise and support the candidacy of millennials and Gen Z for national and state office. The move is meant to restore realism to the national conversation about gun violence. 

Now 23 years old, gun control activist David Hogg survived the 2018 massacre by a former student of Marjory Stoneman Douglas high school in Parkland, Florida. His PAC, Leaders We Deserve, will back candidates under 35 years old for federal office and under 30 years old for state office. Significantly, its executive director is Kevin Lata, former campaign manager for Maxwell Frost, a 25-year-old Democrat from Florida, who is the first member of Gen Z elected to Congress. 

Whatever the outcome of Hogg’s efforts, there is a decided moral force in his argument for young Americans to “to stop hiding… What I see this as is a second step for our generation and the people in power that we’re not just voting, we’re also running. As a generation, we grew up hearing that to survive a school shooting, we had to run, hide and fight”.

The launch of the PAC comes nearly 14 months from the 2024 election, as millennials and Gen Z continue to grow as an influential portion of the electorate. If nothing else, Hogg’s PAC signals an attempt to shift both the perspective – and priorities – of American politics to those of a new generation.

Third, Biden’s America is often hammered by Republicans as the land of rising violent crime, but the numbers tell a different story. An improving portrait of the country emerged from a study of 37 major cities issued in July by the Council on Criminal Justice, a nonpartisan organisation that works to advance understanding of criminal justice policy choices. The study said homicides were down 9% in the first half of this year over the same period last year, and violent crime rates are generally down, though still higher than 2019 levels.

Meanwhile, Biden’s Democrats have spent the past two years trying to reverse the extreme defund-the-police positions some legislators adopted after the May 2020 death of an unarmed black man, George Floyd, at the hands of a white police officer. In November 2021, Democrat Eric Adams, a former police captain, was elected the second black mayor of New York, America’s largest city, on a platform that argued for the role of police in preserving public safety. The Democrats’ more centrist approach to policing is politically savvy of course, but crucially, it also helps to lower the political temperature.

As an American who votes in Florida, my own travels deep in Trump country over the past few years have underlined many of the same messages in real time. In late 2021, for instance, I saw a huge mural go up on the high street in Amherst (population 1,038) a village in central Wisconsin. Deep within a rural part of the state, Amherst is an hour’s drive from Ripon, where the Republican Party was founded in a schoolhouse in 1854. The mural, painted in the shape of a bird by artist Erin LaBonte, quoted Pakistani Nobel laureate Malala Yousafzai on the need for bold political action against injustice: “When the whole world is silent, even one voice becomes powerful.”

In Menomonee Falls, less than two hours away from Amherst, high-street tailor Outkast Alterations displayed hand-lettered signs that read as follows: “We alter clothes but we can’t alter the narratives & existence of injustice & racism experienced by Black & Brown Lives. #BLM”. Another sign in the shop window said “Be proud to stand out”, with a childish rainbow drawn over it. Menomonee Falls is often described as Wisconsin’s most populous village because it has more than 35,000 inhabitants. But its culture and ethos may be better understood by its geographical and political reality. It sits in Waukesha, one of this battleground state’s three most reliably Republican counties. Wisconsin’s so-called WOW counties – Waukesha, Ozaukee, Washington – are mostly well-educated and affluent, and have delivered Republican landslides for decades.

The significance of Outkast Alterations’ message is unmistakable, but doesn’t quite fit with the national political data on Menomonee Falls and Waukesha county. In 2020, Waukesha, which is 92.5% white and less than 2% black, was the Republican Party’s biggest source of votes in Wisconsin. In 2020, Trump beat Biden by more than 10 points here. By some measures, Greater Milwaukee, of which Waukesha is a part, is the most racially segregated metropolitan region in the US. But parts of it still march to a different drummer. Perhaps like much of America. 

As American comic Andy Rooney used to say, it’s amazing how long America has been going to hell without ever having got there. Fragmented, ceaseless change has always been part of the American way. 

Were Alexis de Tocqueville to emerge from the Wayback Machine, the fictional instrument of time travel from the 1960s American cartoon show, it’s not inconceivable that he would still say the same thing he did after his 1831 travels across America: “The greatness of America lies not in being more enlightened than any other nation, but rather in her ability to repair her faults.”

Hello. It looks like you’re using an ad blocker that may prevent our website from working properly. To receive the best experience possible, please make sure any ad blockers are switched off, or add to your trusted sites, and refresh the page.

If you have any questions or need help you can email us.